Tuesday, March 4, 2014

The Social Media Marketing Experience

BACKGROUND
This Storify curation describes my first hands-on experience in social media marketing. Through my Social Media Strategies and Tactics class at Marist College, I created my own blog and learned to optimize and track visitation and engagement with the use of Blogger, Twitter, Pinterest, Facebook and SEO.  What follows is an explanation of this journey.
INTRODUCTION   
I have been a manager of direct marketing for 22 years.  Given the rapidly evolving environment of Internet marketing, I felt I was falling behind the times.  So, I decided to enroll in Marist College’sMaster’s Program in Integrated Marketing Communications.  I enjoy the analytical and strategic facets of business and believe my choice in blog topics reflect these interests.  While I am a lover of the arts and design, I wanted my blog to have a professional, business feel.
PLANS & POLICIES
Goals
My broad overall goals for this course in social media management were to commit myself to the study of social media while mastering the best practices as described by Scott (2013) and Qualman (2013).   This involved developing “relationships directly with consumers like you and me” (Scott, 2013, p. 15) with authenticity and truth.  In this endeavor, my intention was to encourage “interaction, information, education and choice” (Scott, 2013, p. 18).
 
The fundamental goal for my blog was to optimize true engagement.  In order to do so, I had to first understand my blog readers and speak their language.  What were they interested in and why did they come to my blog?  The next aim was to “identify the best way to reach my buyer personas and develop compelling information” (Scott, 2013, p. 169) to attract them.  
 
Ultimately, I wanted my followers to believe in me as a credible source of social media information. To accomplish this I had to truly commit to my blog and its followers, developing a close relationship with readers, informing and educating them to the best of my ability.  I aimed to interact with those who followed my blog in a constructive and respectful way that enhanced learning and encouraged feedback, whether comments agreed or disagreed with my perspective. As in all social media undertakings, the intent was to establish the above with transparency and openness.
 
Objectives
My primary objective was to increase visitation and engagement, more specifically, on my blog through the use of Twitter, Pinterest, Facebook, SEO, and best social media practices as recommended by Scott (2013) and Qualman (2013).  “You have got to engage with your customers on a human level” (Scott, 2013, p. 266). 
 
On a statistical level, the following are the objectives I set for my blog:
 
  • Increase page views originating from Twitter to 20 total.  
  • Increase page views originating from Pinterest to 4 total. 
  • Increase page views originating from G+ to 15 total and Google search to 12 total. 
  • Increase page views originating from Facebook to 25 total.
  • Increase followers to 13 total
  • Average 22 comments per blog per week. 
  • Increase page views to main page to 95 per week
  • Maintain average visit duration of 6 min. 
  • Increase return followers to 5 per week. 
Strategies
In creating content, I focused on my “buyers’” needs, as Scott (2013) suggested. “You should develop an editorial plan to reach your buyers with focused content in the media they prefer” (Scott, 2013, p. 174).  I constructed compelling, transparent, and easy-to-read content while simultaneously applying suggested methods for optimizing performance.
 
Define Audiences
“Building buyer personas is the first step and probably the single most important thing that you will do in creating your marketing and PR plan” (Scott, 2013, p. 164).  Because my main audience consisted of such a small group, I did not feel the need to create buyer personas per se, but I did do research into my readers’ demographics and interests.
Since we were able to comment on any blogs from within our group, I considered my primary audience to be all 14 other individuals within Group A.  Ultimately, I wanted to “know as much as [I] could about this group of people” (Scott, 2013, p.166).
Group A
  • Ages: ranged from 20’s – 40’s.
  • Sex: 10 women (apart from myself) and 4 men.
  • Marital status: at least 7 are married.
  • Geographic location: all from the New York/New Jersey area.
  • 6 Marist graduates of bachelor program.
  • Interests: communications, PR, marketing, sports, cooking, family, pets, the outdoors. “We want to know, in detail, the things that are important for each buyer persona” (Scott, 2013, p. 166).
  • Professions: from daycare worker, restaurant manager and politician to PR representatives and communications managers. Organizations represented: Guess, BMW, P&G, and Marist College.
  • Social media sites frequented: Twitter, Pinterest, Facebook, Blogger
 
Additional Audiences:
  • Bloggers and other professionals outside of our class.
  • Other students and professors outside of our class.

      Content
In order to encourage true engagement, it was essential to “create compelling content” (Qualman p. 224).  I aimed to be concise yet informative. Fostering the two-way exchange of ideas, I remained open to suggestions and ideas other than my own.

             Applications
I promoted by blog through the use of various techniques available from Twitter, Pinterest, Facebook and Blogger. 

Through Twitter I tweeted with hashtags accompanying relevant keywords, addressed potentially interested parties directly and followed my classmates and others in pertinent Marist groups to encourage reciprocity.  By shortening the URL link to my post in with Bitly, I was able to maximize use of my 140 characters.  

I pinned images from my blog to both my personal and our class’ Pinterest board.  I then used permalinks to connect all of the images (on both Pinterest sites) back to my posts.

I commented on both my personal Facebook account as well as the class Facebook group with each blog post. 

In Blogger I applied various techniques to increase integrity, drive traffic and encourage sharing. This began with creating an “about me” page, adding my g+ profile and widgets like g+ follow, g+ recommend, email this, Twitter share, and blog this.
I chose titles and headers carefully, embedded videos and provided links to outside sources.  Images and color were used to add interest, improve comprehension and increase traffic.  “Photos can drive a tremendous amount of traffic by people looking for images via search engines” (Qualman, 2013, p. 221).
By allowing comments on my blog, I was able to shape conversation and foster the open exchange of ideas.  The goal was to keep the conversation relevant and focused.
 
Policy Directly from My Blog
I welcome and encourage constructive feedback and questions in the form of comments.  I will moderate these comments to ensure that they remain appropriate.  I will not reject comments simply because an author's opinions differ from my opinions. In fact, I believe opinions that differ from my own will enrich the content of my blog.  However, please ensure that comments are ethical and respectful of others by avoiding:

  • vulgar language.
  • personal attacks or inappropriate remarks 
  • material that is unrelated to social media.
  • spam, commercial solicitations, or promotion of commercial services and products, political agendas, etc.
  • links to sites that contain material that could offend readers of this site.
  • information that is factually incorrect.
  • any form of discriminatory language
I reserve the right to remove or block authors who violate this policy.

Comments left by others on this site do not necessarily reflect my own views or policies.

This site may discuss matters related to student work and interests. Therefore, site authors must exercise care to ensure that posts and comments on this site comply with FERPA. Refer to the U.S. Department of Education's FERPA website for guidelines.

This site may discuss matters related to student work and interests. Therefore, site authors must exercise care to ensure that posts and comments on this site comply with COPPA. Refer to the U.S. Federal Trade Commission's website for COPPA for more information. Site authors must also ensure compliance with COPPA guidelines published by the Federal Trade Commission (click here for guidelines).

 
ACTIVITIES
First Blog Post
In the first week of posting to our blogs, I had my reservations.  Blogging, tweeting and pinning were all new experiences.  Following recommendations, I included links, images and video on my post.  I sought to keep it simple and incorporated color to aid in guiding the reader.   I added an “about me” page and a Google + profile to increase credibility.





Images used on my blog were pinned to my Pinterest board and our class board as well.  Permalinks were added to the pinned images, linking them back to my post.

Tweeting was a new endeavor.  I applied the basics of hashtags and tweeted directly to
our class, linking every tweet back to my blog with a shortened URL from Bitly.
 


Second Blog Post

By the time I presented my second post, I had gained some confidence.  I provided more links on my blog and embedded the video of buyer persona expert Adele Revella.  Again, I aimed for simplicity and used color and imagery to guide my readers.  I chose appropriate titles to increase the blog’s SEO.


I pinned images from my blog to my own Pinterest board and that of our class as well.  Once again I linked these images back to my corresponding blog post.



On Twitter, I took advantage of Adele Revella’s fame and tagged her name in my tweet.  I was sure to tweet MaristCom610 directly.

In the week of my second blog post, I message “friends” in Facebook regarding my new blog post in addition to our Facebook class group.

Third Blog Post

In my third post, I felt I had finally mastered the art of simplicity.  I kept the concepts basic yet thorough.  I wanted my blog to look clean and professional without being dull.  I again increased the number of links in my post including one to the National Labor Relations Act and one to the NLRB policy template.
 

I once again pinned the images from my post to both Pinterest boards and linked  them to my blog.
 
In this third blog post week, I started tweeting more conscientiously.  I tweeted at different points in the week, became more creative with tags and addressed classmates directly who had not yet followed my blog.  I also tweeted to Steve Lohr, whom I had quoted in my post.


 

ANALYSIS

Followers
I created a spreadsheet in Excel to track followers of my blog.   I had the most followers (eight) in my first blog post, although one was from outside of my group.  In both the second and third weeks, I had six followers.  Team one ceased to follow me after the first post.  Although this was a bit disappointing, there were only two return followers from week one to week two, but five from week two to week three, indicating an increase in engagement.  There were 12 total unique followers from week one to week three.

 
Visit Duration
Average visit duration (tracked through Google Analytics) was five minutes fifty-five seconds. This reflects a considerable degree of engagement in my blog.



Page views
By the end of the third week of blog posts, there were a total of 508 page views.


Referring Sites
Top referring sites were Facebook and Facebook mobile with a total of 42 page views. Runner-up went to Twitter with 24.  G+ came in third place with 16 page views.



Comments
I had 27 comments on my blog in the first week, followed by 24 in the third week and 19 in the second. The average number of comments on my blog per week were therefore 23.33.
 

CONCLUSION
I met or exceeded my targets in 6 areas.  Page views from Twitter, G+, and Facebook surpassed expectations.  Average weekly views to the main page were nine percent higher than projected.

Average comments per week were greater than anticipated and return followers met my expectations. The average visit duration missed the mark by just a hair.

I attribute this accomplishment to my active posting on Twitter and Facebook and the G+ “follow” button on my homepage.  The success in terms of the number of comments per week, return followers and average visit duration was a reflection of my blog content and ability to engage the reader.
 
Total followers missed the mark by just one person.  I overestimated the page views that would be directed from Google but the biggest disappointment was in my Pinterest results. 
If I were to attempt this exercise again, I would be certain to post early in the week.  I would continue my approach on Facebook and Twitter but would make a much stronger effort on Pinterest.  Better educating myself on search engine optimization and targeting those who are not participating in my blog more directly would surely improve my blog statistics.

Lessons Learned
I learned a tremendous amount about social media through this practical experience.  I believe the hands-on application of social media concepts was much more fruitful than a text-only lesson plan would have been.
 
I was able to appreciate the value of simplicity, transparency and credibility in blogging.  Through the coordinated use of Twitter, Facebook, Pinterest and Blogger I personally witnessed the positive results of integrated social media marketing.  Exposure to Google Analytics and Blogger Stats allowed me to appreciate the tools available to statistically prove a blog’s effectiveness.  As a result of this class, I am now confident in my ability to succeed in social media marketing.
 
References:

Scott, D. M. (2013). The new rules of marketing & pr. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
 
Qualman, E. (2013). Socialnomics. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley And Sons, Inc.
 










 
 
 


12 comments:

  1. Hi Susan -

    Congratulations on a great start to your Storify page! I think this offers a great outline of the strategic plan, execution and results from your blog. I especially think you did a great job on your Analysis section.

    I was super impressed to see Facebook as the #1 driver to your blog site. I haven't seen that yet on any other pages, and I think it's something you should absolutely highlight. Through this class, we were only required to post on Pinterest and Twitter. Why do you think Facebook had such great success for your blog? Was there an additional Facebook strategy that helped publicize your blog? If so I think that would be a great thing to share.

    Kristen

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for your comments Kristen. I think Facebook was successful because it is so personal. Anyone in my circle of friends, families and classmates would have seen it. I think that was the real driver. If we were professional bloggers, I suspect we would be able to create that same sort of following on Facebook once we became more established.

    I also did well with Twitter. Pinterest was the only disappointment. I am anxious to see if anyone has any suggestions for me on that front.
    -Sue

    ReplyDelete
  3. Susan, this is a great outline. The Facebook use seems to have been a great idea, I wish I would have used Facebook for my own viewership. The particularly liked how you used charts making it easier for the reader to see the success of your social media activities. Pinterest didn't work out well for me also. I think people usually go on to see ideas about certain projects and create boards, not to be linked to blogs. That's my take on Pinterest after talking to those that enjoy the site.

    What do you think worked best for you on Twitter being that you were fairly new to it?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Andrea-
    Thanks for the feedback. I think it is the personal nature of Facebook that is resposible for its succcess. People go on Facebook to catch up on what is going on in their circles, to find out the latest news. I am not all that familiar with Pinterest, but it seems people are going on with a different interest, as you said. I think they may click a link with the purpose of finding a product or information about a personal interest (maybe that's where the name came from - P interest?) I am curious to see if anyone else had any success at this.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey Susan!

    This is a really great outline! I think that the way it is organized is easy to follow. Also, nice job with the pictures and graphs. It really makes it easy to understand. I particularly like where you inserted your actual tweets. That is going to be something new to me because I have not used Storify before. For me, Pinterest seemed more successful than my Twitter account which I was surprised about since I just began using Pinterest with this class.

    How did you find using Storify? I am a little apprehensive.

    -Michele

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Michele-
    I have not actually moved my work into Storify yet. I have just been "playing-around". It took me a while to understand how to move images from Flikr into Storify. Let me know if you have any problems on that front since I finally figured out what I am doing wrong. Mark actually provided some supporting materials in a message he just sent.

    I am curious to know how you used Pinterest in the class. Can you give me a brief explanation? I and many others did not have much luck. I would love to learn from you.

    Mark message a

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did not really do anything extra with my Pinterest account, but I tried to hashtag relevant topics under my pictures. I noticed that I got likes and re-pins more than I got retweets on Twitter. I think the hashtags under the pictures helped me acquire the attention. Non of my posts got an abundance of attention but Pinterest did better than Twitter.

      -Michele

      Delete
  7. Interesting, thanks. I did get more action on Pinterest this week. I pinned an Excel chart that I created tracking my blog results. Although it wasn't your typical Pinterest image in terms of being pretty, I thought it was unique and interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Susan - fantastic Storify. This looks to be much more than an outline, so perhaps you are editing this entry as we speak! I think the one component that I would like to see more of is in the "Lessons Learned" section. What exactly are you planning to do with this new information? How has it changed your POV on social sharing / media? I think you have knocked this out of the park - but just my two cents :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Susan,

    I found your intro and background sections really interesting. Did you find your marketing experience useful during any particular parts of this project? You also used images really well throughout your storify paper. I liked that I was able to easily follow the story you were trying to tell. Were there any particular social media tools that you found most effective at driving people to your blog?

    Great Post!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Susan,
    This is a great post! I am a relative newbie to social media outside of my personal Facebook page. I have to use it for business purposes which is where I've strugged finding ways to attract followers to my posts and links.

    I have only used my professional Facebook account sporadically, which may explain why I haven't gained much traction on there. I use Pinterest for personal pins, specific to healthy eating and special diet recipes. I have many of my friends following my pins which is good.

    I tend to use Twitter and LinkedIn the most for business-related posts and general use. I am eager to re-read your post to learn how to better reach potential followers and gain traction with my posts overall. Your marketing background, I would believe, provides a good perspective for your approach to the post and how to better penetrate followers.

    Thank you for sharing this!

    ReplyDelete